[Pdns-users] Zone transfer problem from powerDNS to bind

[Marek Turczyniak]

Hello

I'm new to Powerdns. I tried ldapdns but pdns seems to be better.
My problem is zone transfer fom pdns to bind. I have bing 8.3.1 on another
host as slave for nethosting.pl, pdns 2.9.12 as master ( the same problem
was with 2.9.11).
I use ldapbackend (openldap 2.1.22)

In named's log i find:
Oct 18 17:42:47 server named[15422]: reloading nameserver
Oct 18 17:42:47 server named[15422]: Zone "nethosting.pl" (file
nethosting.pl): no NS RRs found at zone top
Oct 18 17:42:47 server named[15422]: slave zone "nethosting.pl" (IN)
rejected due to errors (serial 2003101702)

In pdns logs:

Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: A, priority: 0, content: 217.96.30.194
Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: MX, priority: 10, content: matrix.nethosting.pl
Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: NS, priority: 0, content: ns.nethosting.pl
Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: NS, priority: 0, content: dns.roztocze.com.pl
Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: A, priority: 0, content: 217.96.30.194
Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: MX, priority: 10, content: matrix.nethosting.pl
Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: NS, priority: 0, content: ns.nethosting.pl
Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Search = basedn:
ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl, filter:
(&(associatedDomain=nethosting.pl)(SOARecord=*)), qtype: SOA
Oct 18 17:16:27 matrix pdns[21777]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: SOA, priority: 0, content: ns.nethosting.pl
root at matrix.nethosting.pl 2003101702 1800 3600 604800 84600
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Search = basedn:
ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl, filter: (associatedDomain=nethosting.pl), qtype:
ANY
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: A, priority: 0, content: 217.96.30.194
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: MX, priority: 10, content: matrix.nethosting.pl
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: NS, priority: 0, content: ns.nethosting.pl
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: NS, priority: 0, content: dns.roztocze.com.pl
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: A, priority: 0, content: 217.96.30.194
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: MX, priority: 10, content: matrix.nethosting.pl
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: NS, priority: 0, content: ns.nethosting.pl
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Search = basedn:
ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl, filter:
(&(associatedDomain=nethosting.pl)(SOARecord=*)), qtype: SOA
Oct 18 17:21:22 matrix pdns[21778]: [LdapBackend] Record = qname:
nethosting.pl, qtype: SOA, priority: 0, content: ns.nethosting.pl
root at matrix.nethosting.pl 2003101702 1800 3600 604800 84600


my ldifs:

dn: dc=nethosting,dc=pl,ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl
mXRecord: 10 matrix.nethosting.pl
nSRecord: ns.nethosting.pl
nSRecord: dns.roztocze.com.pl
associatedDomain: nethosting.pl
dc: nethosting
objectClass: dcObject
objectClass: dNSDomain
objectClass: domainRelatedObject
aRecord: 217.96.30.194
sOARecord: ns.nethosting.pl root at matrix.nethosting.pl 2003101702 1800 3600
604800 84600

dn: dc=matrix,dc=nethosting,dc=pl,ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl
aRecord: 217.96.30.194
associatedDomain: matrix.nethosting.pl
dc: matrix
objectClass: dcObject
objectClass: dNSDomain
objectClass: domainRelatedObject
dn: dc=mail,dc=nethosting,dc=pl,ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl
aRecord: 217.96.30.194
objectClass: dcObject
objectClass: dNSDomain
objectClass: domainRelatedObject
associatedDomain: mail.nethosting.pl
dc: mail

dn: dc=www,dc=nethosting,dc=pl,ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl
aRecord: 217.96.30.194
objectClass: dcObject
objectClass: dNSDomain
objectClass: domainRelatedObject
associatedDomain: www.nethosting.pl
dc: www

dn: dc=ns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl,ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl
aRecord: 217.96.30.194
objectClass: dcObject
objectClass: dNSDomain
objectClass: domainRelatedObject
associatedDomain: ns.nethosting.pl
dc: ns

dn: dc=ftp,dc=nethosting,dc=pl,ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl
aRecord: 217.96.30.194
objectClass: dcObject
objectClass: dNSDomain
objectClass: domainRelatedObject
associatedDomain: ftp.nethosting.pl
dc: ftp

dn: dc=bramka,dc=nethosting,dc=pl,ou=dns,dc=nethosting,dc=pl
aRecord: 217.96.30.193
objectClass: dcObject
objectClass: dNSDomain
objectClass: domainRelatedObject
associatedDomain: bramka.nethosting.pl
dc: bramka


Is this bad pdns zone tranfer or too old named?


-- 
Marek Turczyniak